A first 401(k) audit runs on a fixed calendar: the participant count is set on January 1, records are gathered in January and February, fieldwork runs in the spring, and the Form 5500 with the audit report attached is due August 2, 2027 for a 2026 calendar plan year. The sponsors who have the easiest first audit name a coordinator early, know which records each provider holds, and check the common payroll errors before the year closes.
The calendar
- October–December 2026: confirm the count, compare auditors, name a coordinator.
- January 1, 2027: the count is fixed — participants with account balances.
- January–February: census, payroll and recordkeeper reports.
- Spring: fieldwork, findings, corrections begin.
- August 2, 2027: Form 5500 due, audit report attached. October 15, 2027 with a timely Form 5558 — an extension moves the filing, not the audit work.
Who does what
A turnkey service can handle a great deal. Trouble starts when everyone assumes it handles the same things. Name one coordinator, one backup, and a contact at each provider: payroll, the recordkeeper and custodian, and the TPA. You can delegate work; you still need oversight — document decisions, select qualified providers and check that the agreed work is being done.
Records your providers should send
From your company:
- Signed plan document, adoption agreement, amendments and SPD
- Administrator and fiduciary appointments; related entities
- Provider contracts, fee disclosures and fidelity bond
- Prior Form 5500s, prior audits and correction files
- The complete employee population with dates and pay
- Every pay date: deferrals, match, loans and off-cycle runs
- Earnings-code mapping and deduction setup history
- Remittance records matched to trust receipts
From the recordkeeper, custodian and TPA:
- Full-year plan and participant activity
- Prior year-end package (opening balances)
- Contribution receipts and payment records
- Investment certification: institution, period and scope
- Census used for testing and compliance results
- Employer contribution and true-up calculations
- Draft Form 5500
- SOC 1 Type 2 reports and bridge letters
With read-only access to payroll and the recordkeeper, most of the second list is pulled by the auditor, not requested from you.
What usually goes wrong
- Deposits arrive late. Match payroll withholding to actual trust receipt dates. The 15th-business-day limit is not a safe harbor.
- Wrong compensation definition. Compare the plan document to payroll’s earnings-code mapping. Test a bonus run.
- Employees offered the plan too late. Compare hire, rehire and transfer dates with the plan’s entry rules.
- An election never reached payroll. Compare effective-dated elections, Roth designations and auto-enrollment defaults with payroll.
- Match on the wrong formula or period. Recalculate under the document’s formula; prepare a true-up if the plan requires one.
- Documents don’t support the story. Locate signed amendments, distribution approvals and bond coverage for the period. Never recreate dates.
Errors found in November are one adjustment. Found in April, they’re a year of them.
Eight questions to ask any auditor
- What is the engagement partner’s plan-audit background, and how involved will they be?
- How many comparable plan audits has the team done, and may we speak with clients?
- Any disciplinary history — firm or partner — and where can we verify it?
- What relationships or other services could affect independence?
- Can you work from read-only access to our payroll and recordkeeper systems? Can the audit be 100% remote?
- What opening-balance work and investment certification will you need, and who prepares the statements?
- What does the fee include, what can change it, and will documented automation lower it next year?
- Who answers our questions, how are open items tracked, and what milestones will you commit to in writing?
Our answers are in the free first-audit guide, which also covers the first 30 days step by step. Our fixed fees are published: what a 401(k) audit costs. Or get a fixed-fee quote and book a 20-minute call with Charles.
Related questions
- Does my 401(k) plan need an audit? The participant count that matters, the 80–120 rule and the 2027 deadlines.
- How much does a 401(k) audit cost? Our published fixed fees, what they include and how plans qualify for discounts.
- 401(k) audit services at CMR Associates How we work, what you get and how to get started.
About CMR Associates
Charles Renwick, CPA, CFA leads CMR Associates’ 401(k) audit practice and signs every 401(k) audit report. He started his accounting career at Ernst & Young’s Atlanta office, auditing some of the world’s largest financial institutions during the Global Financial Crisis. CMR Associates is a CPA firm founded in 2014 in Mandeville, Louisiana, serving clients in 31 states. Big Four training, without the Big Four fee.
