A 401(k) plan needs an independent audit when it has more than 120 participants with account balances on the first day of the plan year. Between 100 and 120, a plan that filed as a small plan the year before can usually keep filing small under the 80–120 rule. Under 100, no audit is required.
The count that matters
The test is participants with account balances on the first day of the plan year — not headcount, not payroll, and not everyone who is eligible. Your recordkeeper has the number. Ask for it and you’ll know in a day.
- Under 100: no audit.
- 100–120: a plan that filed as a small plan last year can usually elect to keep filing small (the 80–120 rule).
- Over 120: large-plan filing. An independent audit must be attached to the Form 5500. The 80–120 election isn’t available.
We heard the threshold is 100. Why 120?
Both are right. 100 is the normal large-plan line. The 80–120 rule lets a plan that filed small last year keep doing so up to 120. Above 120 the election isn’t available.
When is it due?
For a December 31, 2026 plan year, the Form 5500 with the audit report attached is due August 2, 2027. A timely Form 5558 extends the filing to October 15, 2027. It does not extend the audit work.
The count is fixed on January 1. Records come together in January and February, and fieldwork runs in the spring. Most sponsors hear about a first audit from their TPA in April, with the year closed and the records scattered across payroll, the recordkeeper and the TPA. Find out in November, not April.
Exceptions
These rules are for existing calendar-year plans. New plans, mergers, short plan years and pooled arrangements have their own rules, and a plan that previously filed as a large plan is treated differently. If any of these apply, check before you assume you’re done.
What to do now
- Ask your recordkeeper for the number of participants with account balances on the first day of the plan year.
- If it’s over 120, name a coordinator and a backup, and line up an auditor before year-end. Here’s what a first audit involves.
- Get a fixed-fee quote or book a 20-minute call with Charles. He’ll tell you whether an audit is required — and say so if you don’t need one.
Related questions
- How much does a 401(k) audit cost? Our published fixed fees, what they include and how plans qualify for discounts.
- Your company’s first 401(k) audit: what to expect The calendar, the records to request, common payroll errors and eight questions to ask any auditor.
- 401(k) audit services at CMR Associates How we work, what you get and how to get started.
About CMR Associates
Charles Renwick, CPA, CFA leads CMR Associates’ 401(k) audit practice and signs every 401(k) audit report. He started his accounting career at Ernst & Young’s Atlanta office, auditing some of the world’s largest financial institutions during the Global Financial Crisis. CMR Associates is a CPA firm founded in 2014 in Mandeville, Louisiana, serving clients in 31 states. Big Four training, without the Big Four fee.
Educational content; not a substitute for advice on your plan. The plan document, filing instructions and a written engagement govern each situation.
